My recent article, Prescribe the Work, Observe the Response, prompted an interesting exchange with Johan, one of my readers. He asked whether we spend too much time discussing the physiological objectives of training while paying insufficient attention to what he called the mechanical objectives.

Initially, I thought he was talking about biomechanics, muscular fatigue and the ability of the legs to keep producing force. But after a few emails, it became clear that he meant something rather different. By mechanical, Johan meant the actual output we're trying to achieve: running at 4:40/km, cycling at 320 watts, or delivering a particular performance regardless of how our body responds to it.

His question was essentially this: if the objective of a workout is physiological adaptation, but our physiological response changes from one day to the next, when should we stick to the prescribed pace, and when should we adjust it?

It's a question that gets to the heart of how we prescribe training. But before answering it, there's another distinction worth making.

Pace isn't quite the same as work

We often use pace as a convenient proxy for workload, but strictly speaking, pace measures the result of our efforts rather than the mechanical work required to produce it. And that relationship is not equally predictable across different sports.

On a bicycle, particularly on an indoor trainer, 320 watts gives us a reasonably direct measurement of the mechanical power being delivered to the drivetrain. Running at 4:40/km is different. We know how quickly we're moving, but not precisely how much muscular work is required. Running economy, terrain, technique and environmental conditions all influence that relationship.

Swimming takes this a step further. I might swim at 1:40/100 m on two different days, but the physical and metabolic demands could be quite different depending on my body position, the effectiveness of my catch and how efficiently I move through the water. Equally, I might expend approximately the same amount of energy on two occasions but swim at different speeds simply because I'm swimming better on one day.

Cycling isn't immune to these differences either. Producing the same power at the pedals doesn't guarantee an identical metabolic cost, particularly as fatigue or riding position changes. But measured cycling power provides a more direct representation of external mechanical output than pace does in running or swimming.

That leaves us with at least three things to distinguish: the performance outcome we're prescribing, the mechanical work required to achieve it and the physiological cost of producing that work.

They're related, but they're not interchangeable. This doesn't make pace a poor training target. It simply means we should understand what it measures, and what it doesn't.

The problem with a fixed pace

Imagine a coach prescribes five six-minute intervals at 4:30/km. On Monday, the athlete is rested, the weather is cool and the pace feels comfortable. A few days later, the same session feels considerably harder. Perhaps they slept badly, it's unusually warm, or there's accumulated fatigue from previous training.

Same pace and duration, but potentially a different mechanical demand, a different physiological cost and certainly a different experience.

Johan's approach is to decide beforehand what he's trying to achieve. Sometimes the physiological objective takes priority, and he'll adjust the pace to achieve what feels like the appropriate effort. Other times, he'll deliberately prioritise the external target. He also makes an important observation: deciding that priority in advance helps him evaluate the session afterwards. Missing the prescribed pace doesn't necessarily mean the session was unsuccessful.

I like that thinking. Too often we treat workouts as pass-or-fail exercises based on whether the watch displayed the correct numbers. But there's an assumption hidden in this approach that deserves examining: how reliably can we identify the intended physiological stimulus from how hard the workout feels?

Increasingly, coaches prescribe sessions using terms like "10K effort", "5K effort" or "threshold effort" rather than specific paces. There's a perfectly reasonable argument for doing so. When it's hot, windy or hilly, maintaining a particular pace might produce a very different internal demand from the one the coach intended. Allowing the athlete to regulate intensity by feel lets the external workload change with the conditions.

But what does "10K effort" actually mean? Is it the feeling you remember from your last 10K race, the intensity you could sustain for approximately 40 to 60 minutes, or the effort you experience halfway through a 10K? Those can be quite different things, particularly for runners who haven't raced recently or are moving into unfamiliar territory as their fitness improves.

There's another complication. Perceived effort isn't a direct measurement of physiological stress. Two sessions that feel equally hard need not produce identical metabolic demands, muscular loading or subsequent adaptations. Effort is valuable information, but like heart rate, it's influenced by factors beyond the external workload itself.

So if we replace prescribed pace with prescribed effort, have we really solved the problem? Or have we simply exchanged one imperfect measure for another?

Perhaps we've been asking the wrong question

I think there's another way of approaching this, and it's one reason I've become increasingly interested in controlled sub-threshold training.

What if we select a pace sufficiently below the athlete's sustainable limit that ordinary day-to-day fluctuations rarely threaten the prescription?

In my Norwegian Singles coaching, we use three weekly interval formats: 3 × 10 minutes, 5 × 6 minutes and 10 × 3 minutes, each with its own pace prescription based on the athlete's current performance level. These aren't maximal workouts, nor are they attempts to get as close to threshold as possible without crossing it. They're deliberately controlled, with the intention of accumulating substantial aerobic work at intensities that can be repeated consistently.

That headroom changes the coaching problem. On a good day, the athlete might feel they could run considerably faster. But why should they? The objective isn't to discover today's maximum sustainable pace. It's to complete the prescribed work and recover sufficiently to repeat the process.

On a less favourable day, the same target might feel noticeably harder, but it will often remain achievable without turning the workout into a race. Instead of constantly adjusting pace to reproduce a particular feeling, we've chosen an external target that can usually be repeated across a range of normal physiological responses.

And that headroom isn't only about keeping the cardiovascular response manageable. It may also help preserve movement quality as the training week accumulates. When every interval approaches an athlete's limit, fatigue can begin to affect coordination and running mechanics. Keeping the intensity controlled gives us a better opportunity to accumulate meaningful work while maintaining effective movement and limiting residual fatigue before the next session.

Of course, this is a practical coaching strategy rather than a guarantee of identical training stress. Running economy can change with fatigue, and environmental conditions can change the demands of maintaining a particular speed. Those differences become even more important in technically demanding activities such as swimming.

Extreme heat, illness, inadequate recovery or significant accumulated fatigue can make even a conservative prescription inappropriate. And we should never confuse the ability to force ourselves through a session with evidence that completing it is a good idea.

But I think we underestimate how much of the variability problem can be addressed by choosing sensible training intensities in the first place.

Consistency is an adaptation strategy

There's something attractive about training that doesn't require us to renegotiate the prescription every time we put on our shoes. It encourages discipline when we feel good, because we don't turn every excellent day into an opportunity to run faster. And it provides a useful reference point when we feel bad.

If a pace we've been completing comfortably suddenly feels unusually difficult, that's information. Perhaps we're carrying fatigue, becoming ill, inadequately fuelled or struggling with the conditions. Perhaps our movement has become less economical. We can investigate what has changed rather than automatically accepting that today's subjective feeling should dictate today's workload.

This is also where heart rate and perceived effort remain useful. They help us understand how the athlete is responding, whether the prescribed work is still appropriate and whether the cost is becoming excessive. They don't provide identical information, and neither reveals every relevant physiological process. But together with pace, power and observations of movement quality, they give us a more complete picture than any single number.

The training benefit doesn't come from reproducing an identical heart rate, pace or perceived effort every day. It comes from accumulating appropriate work over time, with sufficient recovery to adapt and continue.

There's also something educational about this process. Athletes learn what sustainable work feels like, develop confidence at unfamiliar speeds and become better at recognising when an apparently difficult day is simply normal variation and when something genuinely needs adjusting.

So when should we ignore the pace?

If we're performing a controlled aerobic workout in reasonably consistent conditions, I generally prefer prescribing the external workload and observing the response. There's no need to run faster simply because the session feels easy, nor to slow down automatically because our heart rate is a few beats higher than last week.

If conditions substantially change the relationship between pace and physiological demand, adjustment makes sense. A steep hill, strong headwind or unusually hot day changes the problem we're trying to solve. Likewise, if an athlete is unusually fatigued or unwell, completing the original prescription may no longer be the sensible objective. In swimming, a noticeable deterioration in stroke quality might be another reason to rethink the pace rather than force an increasingly inefficient movement.

And sometimes the external target is itself part of the purpose. Practising a particular race pace, developing confidence at an unfamiliar speed or learning to maintain effective movement under specific demands can all justify prioritising output. Even then, the cost needs to remain proportionate to the benefit.

Johan put it rather well in his final email. He likes having clear external targets but always wants to remember why those targets exist. He also wants to be satisfied with the session when its purpose has been achieved, even if the numbers haven't.

I think that's excellent coaching logic, although my own approach is probably a little more biased towards prescribing external work. Not because pace or power perfectly represents the work being done, or because repeating an external target guarantees an identical physiological stimulus, but because a sensible prescription gives us a repeatable starting point. We can observe how the athlete responds, identify meaningful changes and adjust when there's a good reason to do so.

The target is the prescription. The purpose is the reason for it. The response helps us decide whether the prescription remains appropriate.

But this exchange also led me towards another question. We've discussed how the cost of maintaining a particular output can vary from one day to the next. What happens when that relationship changes during the session itself, or over the course of a race?

We've all experienced it: breathing is controlled, heart rate doesn't look particularly alarming, but the legs simply won't deliver any more. Or perhaps we're maintaining the same pace, but it's requiring progressively more energy to do so.

Next week that takes us into one of the most fashionable concepts in endurance coaching: durability.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate